Bangladesh and Global Studies · Classes 9-10 · Chapter 1 · 1.3
Discrimination against East Pakistan.
In 1966 the Bengali share of the President's secretariat was 19%, and West Pakistan's was 81%. In a 1956 newspaper report, not one general came from East Bengal. Put the numbers side by side and you can see why the movements took shape. This note holds those numbers, and the method for working with them.
1. How the falling behind began
Pakistan came into being in 1947, and West Pakistani rule and exploitation were established. As a result East Pakistan began to fall behind quickly, and the disparity between the two regions kept growing. The book names the cause plainly: the discriminatory policy of the Pakistan government. Because of that policy, West Pakistan received far more economic benefit.
The book sorts the discrimination into five kinds: economic, administrative, military, educational and social. We take them one at a time.
2. Economic discrimination
From 1955-56 to 1959-60, East Pakistan received only Tk 113 crore 3 lakh 80 thousand of the total budget allocation, while West Pakistan received Tk 500 crore. In the next period, 1960-61 to 1964-65, East Pakistan's allocation was Tk 648 crore (6,480 million) and West Pakistan's was Tk 22,230 crore. Drag the handle to set the two periods against each other. In the first, the West got about four and a half times as much.
Comparing allocations
In each period the West bar is the full length and the East bar is in proportion. Drawn by hand, not measured on a scale.
Allocations were not the only matter. East Bengal's jute, tea and leather earned foreign exchange when they were exported, and most of it was spent on developing West Pakistan. As a result of economic discrimination, East Pakistan fell several times behind in trade, industry, agriculture and every other field.
3. The Bengali share of the administration
East Pakistan's role in the administration was negligible. The 1966 picture of the administration shows a small Bengali share in every department. The nine departments are below. Tap each one to see the East and West shares.
Bengali share by department
| department | Bengali share |
|---|---|
| President's secretariat | ? |
| defence | ? |
| industry | ? |
| home affairs | ? |
| information | ? |
| education | ? |
| health | ? |
| law | ? |
| agriculture | ? |
Exams also ask for a calculation from this table: the gap between the two wings. There is one rule: gap = West's percentage − East's percentage. In agriculture, 79% − 21% = 58%. In health, 81% − 19% = 62%. Many students add by mistake, but the two shares in every row make 100, so adding always gives 100. Type your own answer first, then check it.
Find the gap
The gap is subtracted from the book's table, not printed in the book. What you type goes nowhere. The notebook is yours.
Now the whole table in one picture, with the population line beside it. The East held 56% of the people. Does any department reach that line?
The Bengali share of the administration, 1966
4. Military discrimination
In 1956 the daily Dawn printed a count of military ranks. West Pakistan had 3 generals, 20 major generals and 34 brigadiers. East Bengal had none in these ranks, that is, 0.
Colonels: 49 against 1. Lieutenant colonels: 198 against 2. Majors: 590 against 10. Navy officers: 593 against 7. Air force officers: 640 against 40. In every pair, the West comes first and the East second.
The table in the book's creative question says the same in percentages. Army officers: West 95%, East 5%. Ordinary soldiers: 96% and 4%. High officials of the navy: 81% and 19%. Other navy posts: 91% and 9%.
5. Education and society
Before Pakistan was created, East Bengal was ahead of West Pakistan in primary and secondary education. After it was created, West Pakistan received more than double East Pakistan's education budget, and many new institutions grew up there.
The social result of all these policies, in the book's words: the growth of the middle class in East Pakistan slowed, Bengalis became financially weak, the disparity between the regions grew, and movements took shape. Now sort the evidence into the five kinds of discrimination.
Which discrimination
6. Check yourself
Three questions in the exam's style. Start with the first.
Question 1
The headquarters of Pakistan's defence forces and its arms factories were in the western wing. Only 4 percent of the army's members were Bengalis. Most of the military budget was spent in West Pakistan. Which side of the Pakistani rulers' discrimination does the passage show?
The second, with a little thought.
Question 2
East Pakistan's development was held back:
i. because of the rulers' discrimination
ii. because less money was allocated to East Pakistan
iii. because it imported and exported less
In the last, recall the numbers.
Question 3
Why was West Pakistan better off than East Pakistan?
The whole note on eight cards.
Eight cards
This chapter's board questions, with answers and reasons →
Source: Bangladesh and Global Studies, Classes 9-10 (NCTB), Chapter 1 “The Political Movement in East Bengal and the Rise of Nationalism (1947-1970)”, section 1.3.